[He can almost feel the heated splash regardless.]

Ack! Er... Objection! Some of what you said might be true. Except that Dahlia might be a vengeful killer... but she's not dumb! She can't make a move while we outnumber her- while someone like you is hounding around! There are other killers with grudges here too and yet nothing's happened yet!

You are right in one way. We don't know if this thing will play fair! But at the same time, that evidence is all we have to go by! How is going in blind to find this badger any better a strategy?!